CD Review: Rachel Brown – A Tribute to Bach
February 16, 2017 (No Comments) by Ganved14

Rachel-Brown-BachIt has taken far too long to prepare this review but my procrastination has been occasioned by the sheer scope and beauty of this recording. I received this double CD just prior to meeting Rachel Brown and hearing her perform the Quantz A Major Concerto with the London Handel Players at London’s Wigmore Hall in April. My first response to both the concert and the recording has been a kind of awe that has persisted for several months, not only of Ms. Brown’s artistry but of the depth and power of the Baroque repertoire in general and J.S. Bach in particular.

No-one needs convincing about the genius of J.S. Bach, and no performer of his flute music can doubt its importance to the repertoire, but this collection can only reinforce that impression.

Rachel Brown

Rachel Brown

Rachel Brown is the undisputed doyen of Baroque flute artists in the United Kingdom, probably in the world, not only as a performer but also as a historian and practicing musicologist. Her “. . . pure, silky smooth and wonderfully expressive flute sound” (Göttinger Tageblatt, 2013) is backed up by a deep knowledge of the Baroque repertoire that has resulted in acclaimed recordings of the Telemann Fantasias and sonatas and concertos by JS, CPE and JC Bach, Handel, Quantz and Leclair. Here it manifests as the detailed notes (and translations) that accompany this recording as well as her reconstruction of the A Major Sonata (BWV 1032) and her arrangement of the A Minor Concerto (BWV 1056) that make up a significant part of it. In addition, her inclusion of the flute solos from the Easter Oratorio and from several cantatas, as well as Bach’s transcription of the Vivaldi violin concerto, greatly expands our awareness of the J.S. Bach flute repertoire beyond the sonatas and partitas normally presented in such collections. [Flute students who resist music history classes take note!]

Needless to say, these are consistently beautiful and most welcome additions to our awareness of the scope of Bach’s writing for flute. In her program notes, (which can be downloaded at: Brown reveals the source of her inspiration. Referring to Bach as “. . . one of the greatest composers and perhaps one of the greatest geniuses of all time” she notes that “. . . it is his ability to touch the heart and stir the soul which makes his music so inspirational.” She continues:

The inspiration for this disc stemmed from my sheer wonder at Johann Sebastian Bach’s rich and hugely varied compositions for the flute and from a deep and ever-growing respect for the unquestionably admirable flautists who performed for him and inspired him to write in such new and both technically and expressively demanding ways.

Johann Gottfried Bernhard Bach

Johann Gottfried Bernhard Bach

She goes on to mention one of his older brothers, Johann Jakob, and his third son, Johann Gottfried Bernhard, who were both flautists, but concludes that while it is not known for whom Bach composed his flute sonatas, etc.:

. . . almost more than any other composer, including flautist-composers, Bach seems to have understood the innate qualities of the flute . . . using it to its fullest capabilities and pushing it up to and beyond any hitherto known boundaries of its technique, but all for greatest poignant rhetorical and dramatic effect.

What remains to point out is that, driven by her wonder of Bach’s achievement, and supported by the depth of her performance capabilities (as well as those of her accompanists), Rachel Brown has produced a recording that more than meets the challenge of this repertoire and belongs in the collections of every music library and every serious flute artist.

Rachel Brown and The London Handel Players

Rachel Brown and The London Handel Players

Disc 1

Adagio from the opening Sinfonia to Easter Oratorio, BWV 249
Sonata in B minor for obbligato harpsichord and flute, BWV 1030
Bete aber auch dabei from Cantata Mache dich, mein Geist, bereit, BWV 115
Solo (Partita) in A minor, BWV 1013
Sonata in A major for obbligato harpsichord and flute, BWV 1032
Doch weichet, ihr tollen vergeblichen Sorgen! from Cantata Liebster Gott, wenn wird ich sterben?, BWV 8

Disc 2

Ich habe genug from Cantata Ich habe genug, BWV 82a
Sonata in E minor for flute and basso continuo, BWV 1034
Ermuntre dich, dein Heiland klopft from Cantata Schmücke dich, o liebe Seele, BWV 180
Flute Concerto in A minor, BWV 1056 (arr. Brown)
Wo wird in diesem Jammerthale from Cantata Ach, lieben Christen, seid getrost, BWV 114
Sonata in E major for flute and basso continuo, BWV 1035
Largo from Bach’s transcription of Vivaldi’s violin concerto RV 299, BWV 973

Rachel Brown – flute
Laurence Cummings – harpsichord
Katherine Sharman – cello and cello piccolo
Adrian Butterfield and Oliver Webber – violins
Peter Collyer – viola
Peter Buckoke – double bass
Elizabeth Cragg – soprano
Charles Daniels – tenor
Peter Harvey – baritone


Peter WestbrookReview by Peter Westbrook


Comments are closed.

Editor in Chief